How do you choose a kitchen island color in Rancho Santa Fe?

Last Updated: November 10, 2022

Okay, so you’ve got JUST the right kitchen cab­i­net paint col­or picked out. Maybe it’s styl­ish, but not TOO trendy, eye-catch­ing but doesn’t dom­i­nate the space. You nailed it.

Not to throw a curve­ball, but what about your island itself?

Sure, you can paint your kitchen island to match your cab­i­nets. There’s noth­ing wrong with that. But… is it a missed oppor­tu­ni­ty? The truth is, a lot of folks who are paint­ing cab­i­nets in San Diego (and beyond!) are opt­ing for some­thing more when it comes to the island. It’s a unique space and has the poten­tial to be real­ly stunning.

Let’s run through some of your options. Ready?

Should my kitchen island match my cabinets?

Build­ing on what we men­tioned before, your island CAN match but doesn’t have to. Many home­own­ers are using this valu­able real estate as a way to com­ple­ment their cab­i­net col­or, but not match it per­fect­ly. Besides, islands are a real hub of fam­i­ly life and activ­i­ty — giv­ing them their own per­son­al­i­ty can have a nice effect.

Should my island col­or be lighter or dark­er than my cabinets?

The not-so-help­ful answer? It’s up to you. But typ­i­cal­ly you want it to be an accent, mean­ing that it swings the oppo­site direc­tion from your cab­i­net col­or. If your kitchen cab­i­nets are light (as most are), go with a dark­er, bold­er island col­or. But if your cab­i­nets are dark, you could go with either a lighter island, a com­ple­men­tary dark col­or, or a more nat­ur­al fin­ish like stain. In most cas­es though, a dark­er col­or is the first choice.

What are pop­u­lar kitchen island paint colors?

White and gray are ALWAYS ​ “ in.” But these days blue and green are sneak­ing to the front of the pack. And there are so many vari­eties and options to choose from! If you love bold, go with a dark green, but if you love a more sub­dued, airy palette, soft greens that are root­ed deeply in nature are a home­run. In fact, with all the vari­eties and options at your dis­pos­al, you might want to talk with a pro­fes­sion­al col­or con­sul­tant before paint­ing. They can open your eyes to some fresh options you might nev­er have oth­er­wise considered. 

A real-life exam­ple of kitchen island paint­ing in Ran­cho San­ta Fe

Noth­ing beats see­ing the real thing. Here’s a gor­geous kitchen island our team recent­ly paint­ed, fea­tur­ing a green col­or. And if you peek in the back­ground, you’ll see that the rest of the cab­i­nets are dark as well, but the island still stands out in a sub­tle way. We love the less shiny sheen too — very trendy these days. 

October 26, 2026
Ocean-facing and bay-facing Point Loma homes can weather differently. Learn how wind, moisture, sun, and exposure affect exterior painting and maintenance.
October 26, 2026
Is your Point Loma wood garage door weathered or peeling? Learn when refinishing, repainting, repairing, or replacing it makes the most sense.
October 26, 2026
Repairing a deck or balcony in Point Loma? Learn when to schedule structural repairs, waterproofing, railing work, and exterior painting.
October 26, 2026
Weathered porch, deck, or entry wood in Coronado? Learn when refinishing or repainting makes sense and when damaged wood should be repaired or replaced.
October 26, 2026
Rust appearing on your Coronado home's gates, railings, or metal trim? Learn when surface prep and repainting are enough and when repairs are needed.
October 26, 2026
Repainting a Coronado home with wood siding, shingles, or stucco? Learn how coastal exposure, material condition, and preparation affect painting.
October 26, 2026
Repairing exterior woodwork on a Coronado home? Learn when to complete carpentry, siding repairs, sanding, priming, and painting for lasting results.
October 23, 2026
We couldn’t be more excited to share that Chism Bros. Painting has received the 2026 Best of La Jolla award from La Jolla Village News, earning a Gold Medal. We're honored, humbled, and incredibly grateful. Awards like this aren't really about the company alone. They're about the people who invite us into their homes, recommend us to their neighbors, and keep calling us back year after year. So before anything else, we want to say thank you.  To La Jolla and Our Longtime Customers La Jolla has been good to us. We've painted its craftsman bungalows, its coastal homes (salt air keeps us on our toes), and plenty of places in between. Many of you have trusted us with more than one project, and some of you have been with us for decades. That kind of loyalty isn't something we take lightly. Every repeat call, every referral, and every kind review is the reason a recognition like this is possible. We appreciate you. A Family Business Built on Trust Since 1982 All of this is especially important to us since Chism Bros. is a multigenerational family painting company, and that shapes how we work and how we grow. When your name is on the truck (and your family's name before you), you know how critical relationships and trust really are. For more than 40 years, we've run on character and craftsmanship, and this kind of recognition is confirmation that we’re on the right track. What Comes Next Honestly? More of the same. Same careful prep, same clear communication, same crews who treat your home like it belongs to family. An award is a nice moment, but the real measure is how we handle the next project. We're proud to keep serving La Jolla and the greater San Diego area, inside and out. Frequently Asked Questions Q. Who was named Best Painter in La Jolla for 2026? Chism Bros. Painting won Best Painter, with a Gold Medal, in the 2026 Best of La Jolla awards from La Jolla Village News. Q. How long has Chism Bros. Painting been in business? Chism Bros. has served San Diego since 1982. It is a multigenerational, family-run painting company. Q. What painting services does Chism Bros. offer in La Jolla? Residential and commercial painting, including interiors, exteriors, cabinet painting and refinishing, historic restorations, deck care, and color consultations. Q. Is Chism Bros. Painting licensed? Yes. Chism Bros. holds California Contractor License #491884. Let's Talk About Your Next Project Thinking about a fresh coat, inside or out? We'd be glad to take a look. Call us at 858.454.3850 or request a free estimate here on our website. Thank you again, La Jolla. We'll keep earning it.
October 23, 2026
Should you paint walls, trim, and doors together or in phases? Learn how Carmel Valley homeowners can prioritize interior painting by condition and budget.
October 23, 2026
Noticing cracks around windows or doors? Learn what Carmel Valley homeowners should check and repair before exterior painting begins.

Tell us about your project

Tell Us About Your Project

Contact us today to schedule a visit from one of our estimators! We’ll come to your home and provide a detailed estimate.


(858) 454-3850


Est 1982